The idea of using pre-cloak comic superheroes as tools for the empowerment of children has drawn notice from a multitude of corners: e.g., documentary filmmakers, a journalist from Forbes, the Joseph Campbell Foundation (2016). It has predictably drawn interest from adoption networks and support groups, as well as agencies that deal with foster children. I say ‘predictably’ because these groups of at-risk children were the groups a recent study (Fradkin et al. 2016) aimed to serve. As the findings in the ‘pre-cloak’ study noted: of the top-20 comic superheroes, 86% were orphaned or abandoned, in addition to enduring other woes. My co-authors and I stressed that this shared history has potential for empowerment: When these children hear of hardships overcome by superheroes, that may strengthen their resolve to carry on.
A program that employs the pre-cloak stage of superheroes has been active in Rwanda for some time. At the Rwandan Orphans Project (a center that serves former street children) (2016), a life-skills group implemented by Lisa Meaney, MFT, has used superhero origin stories to inspire its orphaned boys (Figure 1). “For these boys,” Meaney writes (2016, pers comm., 3 May), “childhood trauma can be a catalyst for positive change … Just like it is for superheroes.” For two years Meaney has incorporated superhero origin stories into her group-work with Rwandan boys. On Meaney’s watch, superhero capes were made from old t-shirts, masks from cereal boxes. “Over and over again,” she says, “the boys have made statements such as, ‘If Batman can be an orphan and be a superhero then so can I’” (2016, pers comm., 22 April). When asked about the boys’ openness to the disproportionately large percentage of Caucasian superheroes (~90%), Meaney reassured me that for her boys, the notion of a superhero role model is stronger than the color lines of race.
5,000 miles WSW of Rwanda is a program in São Paulo, Brazil. The ‘Superformula’ program at the A.C. Camargo Cancer Center (2016), attempts to raise the spirits of its pediatric patients using special comics, videos, and superhero plastic covers for IV bags (Figure 2). The children are encouraged to do battle with their cancer, as the comic superheroes battle evil. Their chemo drip is ‘Superformula.’ While this approach may first seem novel, over time it may wear thin, as many patients on the ward will lose their battle. The Superformula program instills hope upon the ward, through the premise of ‘invincibility suggestion.’
So where to go? I pondered on the future of the project; an effort conceived in several stages. The Rwandans were standing in the background. Therapists were asking what to do…. The cart was put in motion; it was rolling down the hill; but still, the next step was elusive. Then, bang! the answer hit me: A compilation! A directory for the therapists; in particular, those who work with high-risk children. I envisioned a sleek database; a gold-foil embossed book. I celebrated, having settled on direction. My compass was following the course.
But in the morning, I felt weary after tallying the workload: a directory of comic superheroes’ pre-empowered woes. Rebuking my resistance, I began. I sent word out to my students: from the past, the present, future: Would you like to gain some credit for your CV? When I mentioned comic superheroes, their eyes lit up like candles; one offered to enroll his aging mother. So, the routine was established: they would toil through DVDs, noting hardships and abuses that the superheroes suffered, in the pre-cloak stage, before empowerment. One student went to Batman (1989); another to the Hulk (2003); a third said he would work with Spider-Man (2002).
The gears were grinding slowly. The students, as research assistants, buckled down. A directory was slowly in the works. At this stage we built the format in an Excel spreadsheet, time-coded from main title to the end. The time-code ran from top to bottom on the left-hand column, with adversities and comments to the right. Every hardship from each film was logged: pre-cloak and post. They were coded for the different categories: loss of parents, bullying, poverty, abuse; romance problems, hardships while at school. In the end, we finalized two separate versions for each film: the first in chronological from downbeat to the end; the second chronological by hardship (e.g., bullying: from main title through the scroll; then hardships while at school in the same format). We opted for this doubling to allow the therapist quick access to focus on one specific hardship. The students worked in shifts, scene-to-scene they chugged along. Assistant Chua logged bullying (00:03:55–00:04:26), in Spider-Man 3 (2007): ‘During lecture, Parker’s classmates are shooting spitballs at him … [then they’re] shining light into his eyes.’ Assistant Sullivan logged loss of parents (01:30:15–01:32:10), in a flashback from Batman (1989): He notes Bruce Wayne and his parents walking from a movie theatre … He then describes the details of their murder.
As progress inches forward, challenges arise. In terms of presentation … Should the pre-cloak stage be separate from the post-? Should categories meld into each other? Should the series of the films (e.g., Spider-Man , Spider-Man 2 , Spider-Man 3 ) be listed one-after-the-other, or stand-alone—independently? Decisions will be made; options will be weighed. And opinions gathered from disparate sources. The directory, when whole, will be reviewed by focus groups: by critics, colleagues, friends and foes alike.
So here I sit. Contemplating the potential of pre-cloak comic superheroes. While Deadpool (2016) slaughters the box office; the Force Awakens (2015) breaks the roof; X-Men: Apocalypse (2016) has come and gone; likewise Independence Day: Resurgence (2016). Doctor Strange (2016) is coming soon; while next year: Wonder Woman (2017); Spider-Man (Spider-Man: Homecoming 2017). On this planet of consumers, we can never get our fill: our addiction is to heroes on the screen. Make them larger than we are; give me guidance like a star; and in the process show the path my feet should go.
The author would like to express grateful acknowledgement to research assistants Troi Chua, James Sullivan, and Chelsea Phelps.
The author declares that they have no competing interests.
A. C. Camargo Cancer Center (2016). Available at: http://www.accamargo.org.br/english/ (Accessed 14 May 2016).
Batman (1989). Burton, Tim USA: Warner Bros. [film].
Deadpool (2016). Miller, Tim USA: 20th Century Fox. [film].
Doctor Strange (2016). Derrickson, Scott USA: Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures. [film].
C Fradkin, G V Weschenfelder, M A M Yunes, (2016). Shared adversities of children and comic superheroes as resources for promoting resilience: Comic superheroes are an untapped resource for empowering vulnerable children. Child abuse & neglect 51 : 407. DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.chiabu.2015.10.010
Hulk (2003). Lee, Ang USA: Universal Pictures. [film].
Independence Day: Resurgence (2016). Emmerich, Roland USA: 20th Century Fox. [film].
Joseph Campbell Foundation (2016). Available at: https://www.jcf.org (Accessed 26 March 2016).
J. Walter Thompson Brazil (2016). Superformula to fight cancer. Available at: https://www.jwt.com/en/brazil/work/superformulaparalutarcontraocancer/ (Accessed 15 May 2016).
Rwandan Orphans Project (2016). Available at: http://www.rwandanorphansproject.org/ (Accessed 14 May 2016).
Spider-Man (2002). Raimi, Sam USA: Columbia Pictures. [film].
Spider-Man 2 (2004). Raimi, Sam USA: Columbia Pictures. [film].
Spider-Man 3 (2007). Raimi, Sam USA: Columbia Pictures. [film].
Spider-Man: Homecoming (2017). Watts, Jon USA: Columbia Pictures. [film].
Star Wars: The Force Awakens (2015). J. J. Abrams, USA: Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures. [film].
Wonder Woman (2017). Jenkins, Patty USA: Warner Bros. Pictures. [film].
X-Men: Apocalypse (2016). Singer, Bryan USA: 20th Century Fox. [film].